Shameless

On March 7, 2013 by ali heller

photo copy 4

For women here, shame (or, kunya) is a way of life.  It’s hard for me to keep up with everything that causes it.

Saying the name of your husband out loud brings a woman shame. A girl’s first pregnancy is so shrouded in shame that it goes unacknowledged (which, as you can imagine, has many consequences for seeking prenatal care or timely obstetric interventions). “Ta cin wake”, “She ate beans” people say. Expected to deliver alone and completely unassisted, I asked a 15 year-old girl who had taught her what to do when the time came – what to expect. She covered her face, embarrassed, and shook her head: “No one”. Such a conversation between mother and daughter would be too shameful. I’m told that if you cry during delivery, but are then seen playing with your child, you will feel ashamed. Indeed, a mother’s relationship with her first child is characterized by shame (according to Baba of Karo, a beautiful biography written about a Hausa woman in the 1950s: “the mother refuses to look at him, she refuses to touch him, she hides her hands and covers her head and face. It is her first child, she is very embarrassed . . . The child’s mother always remains ashamed of him”).

Today I was told that if you say the name of your mother-in-law out loud, not only will you be shamed, but when you die, you will “only see black” and you won’t ascend to heaven. I’ve been told that women will go months with painful gynecological conditions because they are ashamed to even indicate where there’s pain. Women avoid coming to health centers to give birth due to the shameful exposure that biomedical birthing requires (understandable – stirrups don’t do much to protect modesty).

Shame!
When I show women pictures of Adam, they cover their faces, shriek and giggle, and say “Don’t you feel shame!?”
Shame?
Shame of what?

The never-ending quest to avoid shame guides so much of women’s daily behavior, dress, and health-seeking choices.

During interviews, in cool and measured voices, women walk me through the obstetric catastrophes that caused their injuries. Today, a woman told me about her 5-day labor, a half delivered child, it’s gruesome extraction, and the constant flow of fecal mater she discovered upon awaking from a 2-week coma. She didn’t cry, she didn’t wince. I asked my research assistant how she could handle such loss and pain with such a perfected poker face. I was told that the shame an emotional reaction would bring would be nearly as bad as what had already happened. (Hyperbole, I’m sure.)

Clearly shame isn’t the only force at play. Still, in some ways women here remind me of spaghetti-western cowboys. Stoic. Silent. Unemotional. Private. If it weren’t for the hubris of Marlboro men, they’d be spot on.

Quick to laugh, quick to cry, and not easily embarrassed, I can only imagine what these heroines think of me…
Utterly shameless indeed.

photo_5

photo_4

photo_3

photo_2

photo_5

 

photo_6

photo_4 photo_3

photo_2 photo_1 photo (31) photo (30)

3 Responses to “Shameless”

  • James H

    curious what the treatment of children is like, how the socialization into a culture of shame progresses – are the expectations that children stop showing outward signs of discomfort and develop self-control by teens? earlier? interesting post…

    • ali heller

      Hi James! Good point/question! Parenting and childhood are really interesting subjects here. Briefly, children (particularly girls) are not cut much slack regarding outward shows of emotion. Parents don’t respond to crying children, and once old enough to walk around, parents ridicule children for crying. Little girls (as young as 3) often wear hijabs and are taught modesty and shame. Once a girl is 8 or 9, she’s basically a small adult, and will respect most adult codes of behavior. At this age, girls are often primary care takers of younger siblings. The average age of first marriage (according to DHS) is 15 (many married much younger)– so, by puberty any semblance of ‘childhood’ is often finished. I don’t know much about boys to be honest (particularly young teens). I’ll have to look in to it more, although I imagine it’s the same/ similar.

  • Abbas Hajari

    it is so sad that people get brainwash with that kind of
    nonesense , and they do all that in the name of
    religiones . I think the problem start with lack
    educations , and unfortunatly we have the same
    problem in this country , lack of right education .
    I mean

Leave a Reply to Abbas Hajari Cancel reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *